[CT Birds] Rough-winged Swallow id.
julian hough
jrhough1 at snet.net
Thu Nov 29 13:52:55 EST 2007
While debate about late Northern Roughwings continues, another species to consider, one brought up personally by Shai Mitra, is Yucatan Rough-winged Swallow, previously unrecorded in the US but a potential candidate for vagrancy.
see
http://www.martinreid.com/Main%20website/roughwing.html
Clinal nature of rough-winged swallows means that there are few distinguishing sub-specific characters obvious in the field that would differentiate out of range individuals. The Northern and Southern Rough winged Swallows may differ in the field as posted previously by Greg Hanisek. However, a third taxon ridgwayi, or Yucatan Roughwinged Swallow is regarded as a distinct species but most likely more difficult to separate from Northern than Southern would be. Basically the features that would distinguish these from Northern Rough-winged are:
Pale loral spots
larger and darker than NRSW
Dusky undertail coverts (with dark spots)
more forked tail
These features are subtle and hard to see in the field on a flying bird, especially when lighting may affect how dark or light a birds' plumage appears in the field.
A closer look at the birds at East Shore would be in order to check out these features, especially if any one of the bird's looks darker or larger (assuming all are not of the same species).
Julian
More information about the CTBirds
mailing list