[CT Birds] Broadwing Hawks in winter

[Carrier Graphics]

    I would also if I may, like to ad to Greg and Daves very astute observations on reports of Broadwing hawks seen here in Ct during our winter months.  In the 35 plus years I have hawk watched in this state, The reports of  seeing Broadwing hawks past November or earlier then March are few and far between. I also agree with Greg in stating the sightings of any possible Broadwing here in the winter months needs a full and detailed description of the bird seen. In fact, the sighting of a Broadwing hawk anywhere in North America during the winter months should be suspect.  

    Though adults of the Red shoulder and Broadwing hawks are quite different in coloring and patterns and can often be separated quit quickly, the differences between Immature birds of these two species is often difficult at best ,even for well experienced hawk watchers, let alone those who are not familiar with the immatures of these two different species. The similarities of the two are so subtle and often so variable, it takes time to separate the two. Many experienced hawkwatchers often use shape, flying style and proportional sizing for the identification of Immature Red shoulders or Broadwings rather then their coloring or patterns.

    Though Red shoulders are becoming a much more common sight in CT during the winter, Broadwings in all respects should not even be here at all. If you do happen to see what you believe to be a Broadwing, it needs a complete and thorough written description and submission to our COA rare records committee.

Respectfully submitted - Paul Carrier