[CT Birds] Grouse in CT - promise my last word...
carriergraphics at sbcglobal.net
Sun Nov 2 10:36:56 EST 2014
Shaun - Yes, that's how the State lets the people know Hunting isn't the problem. But I am NOT saying hunting IS the problem for their decline! But by continuing to hunt Grouse IS one of the factors that contributes to keeping the population from growing. That seems so simple to understand for me and many others.
YES, their are other reasons for their decline, but shooting them sure doesn't help. Why does the State continue to allow the hunting of Grouse, when they also know of all the other factors that lead to their loss in our State? Each factor that helps the Grouse, like new habitat, is great when we do it. But to continue to have an open season to kill them seems counter productive to me. But - seems that's how our State works. Shows their concern by studying and trying to improve habitat Etc, but keeps the hunters happy and money coming in anyway. Counter productive i would say...
- And, all this talk for so long from the State about research and studies to find a solution or find the problem why Grouse are declining. I can tell you now with certainty - GROUSE ARE DECLINING! and have been for many years! Now save some money from your long research and do something about that, Produce more suitable habitat and STOP SHOOTING THEM in the MEANTIME!
Paul Carrier -
From: Shaun Martin <birdj510 at gmail.com>
To: Carrier Graphics <carriergraphics at sbcglobal.net>
Cc: ctbirds <ctbirds at lists.ctbirding.org>
Sent: Saturday, November 1, 2014 10:49 PM
Subject: Re: [CT Birds] Grouse in CT - promise my last word...
Once again, I believe hunting pressure is being blamed or made the reason for lack of numbers without merit. I wonder that on the counts that were previously mentioned, how many of those areas were actually huntable pieces of land. That would be an interesting comparison.
It is nice to think, if hunting stopped, the birds would be more prevalent, but that's not the case. There are so many other limiting factors. CT's wildlife managers most certainly look at Grouse population dynamics to determine bag limits. Look up Compensatory Mortality and it will show why hunting is at the bottom of the list for population decline. Based on the science, any bird potentially harvested would be killed off by another variable during a hunting ban.
Stopping hunting won't SAVE the few Grouse we have left. Habitat management and protection would be more along those lines. Look at the whole picture, use Wildlife Management techniques. It's easy to blame hunting, but its more productive to blame the actual reasons and try to turn the decline around that way.
Donna Rose sent me an interesting bit on Grouse in CT. see below - Thanks Donna.
I will read this and I do believe the State is doing research on Grouse. But - Now-while they are scarce and even depleted in many areas, habitat is crucial, but first let's SAVE the birds we now have so they can occupy the new habitat the State is making! It's all about getting a healthy population started once again, not destroying the few birds we now have that are left. I say to the - State of Connecticut . . .
Keep making new habitat, that is a good thing. but FIRST - stop hunting the few Grouse that we have left so when the habitat is there, they can colonies it and become a healthy population once more! Why is this just so hard for the State to accept? A few Grouse hunters might cry for awhile, but by doing so, in the future they might even be able to find 8 Grouse a season to shoot! Let's benefit the hunters, the bird watchers and the State in making this a priority, and we then can all be happy once again, especially the Grouse!
ps - and to help with research for the State. Ruffed Grouse are doing poorly in your State! Ask anyone. Yes-in a few areas they might be doing fair. I would agree with some Hartland areas, but they are few or gone all together in many more historical areas where they once were present in good numbers. There, now you don't need more research while the population is so poor and dwindeling - it is poor! Please cut the hunting of Grouse till their numbers are healthy once again.
This list is provided by the Connecticut Ornithological Association (COA) for the discussion of birds and birding in Connecticut.
For subscription information visit http://lists.ctbirding.org/mailman/listinfo/ctbirds_lists.ctbirding.org
More information about the CTBirds