PCW] PDQ 34 Fuel Efficiency

H
HClews@aol.com
Tue, Jul 25, 2006 4:58 PM

Mark,

See my previous post...  No,  we don't have FloScan meters, I wish we did!
Unfortunately, they're  quite expensive and somewhat complicated for a twin
diesel.  Nevertheless, I am considering installing them.  (I'd love to know the
exact figures too.)

You're right, it does appear that the boat  has two optimal speeds. We get
about 7 knots at a mere 1500 RPM.  At this speed (which feels like a fast idle)
the boat is so quiet  we're always surprised to see 7 - 7.5 knots on the GPS.
But, much like a  planning, or semi-displacement monohull, increasing the
throttles  from 1800 to 3000 RPM seems to increase the wake size but not  to
offer a commensurate speed increase.  From 3000 RPM on up to  WOT (3800) the boat
feels as though its planning, the bow actually comes down a  bit and the wake
gets smaller.

At engine speeds above 3000  RPM there is quite a bit of noise in the main
cabin.  (This can be  reduced slightly by closing the aft cabin doors.)  It's
not really  objectionable - I believe PDQ has the actual figures on their
website.  However, up on the flying bridge, where I normally am in fair weather,
it's very  quiet.  At 7 knots you hear the water noise above the engines -
reminiscent  of sailing!  At 3200 RPM (16-knots) you're aware of the engines, but
you really have to listen carefully to tell if they are synchronized.  (Not
that it really matters - unless you've got OCD - like me!)  Neither  Nancy or I
have found noise to be a problem.  (But you're right, it's hard  to make a
light boat quiet.)

Henry Clews
aboard Sno' Dog in Newington,  NH
www.geocities.com/snodoglog

In a message dated 7/25/2006 11:40:56 A.M.  Eastern Daylight Time,
mark424x@yahoo.com writes:

Henry,

5gph at 15knots is quite good.  Do you have a fuel  flow meter - just curious
if the consumption is fairly linear with speed up to  that point or if there
are big gains  by dropping back to ~11-12?  It seems that most folks either
stay at 7-8 or crank it up to 15-16 if they  are able.

Could you also comment on the interior noise at  cruise.  Often the
lightweight designs don't do great with noise  isolation.

Thanks,

Mark

Mark, See my previous post... No, we don't have FloScan meters, I wish we did! Unfortunately, they're quite expensive and somewhat complicated for a twin diesel. Nevertheless, I am considering installing them. (I'd love to know the exact figures too.) You're right, it does appear that the boat has two optimal speeds. We get about 7 knots at a mere 1500 RPM. At this speed (which feels like a fast idle) the boat is so quiet we're always surprised to see 7 - 7.5 knots on the GPS. But, much like a planning, or semi-displacement monohull, increasing the throttles from 1800 to 3000 RPM seems to increase the wake size but not to offer a commensurate speed increase. From 3000 RPM on up to WOT (3800) the boat feels as though its planning, the bow actually comes down a bit and the wake gets smaller. At engine speeds above 3000 RPM there is quite a bit of noise in the main cabin. (This can be reduced slightly by closing the aft cabin doors.) It's not really objectionable - I believe PDQ has the actual figures on their website. However, up on the flying bridge, where I normally am in fair weather, it's very quiet. At 7 knots you hear the water noise above the engines - reminiscent of sailing! At 3200 RPM (16-knots) you're aware of the engines, but you really have to listen carefully to tell if they are synchronized. (Not that it really matters - unless you've got OCD - like me!) Neither Nancy or I have found noise to be a problem. (But you're right, it's hard to make a light boat quiet.) Henry Clews aboard Sno' Dog in Newington, NH www.geocities.com/snodoglog In a message dated 7/25/2006 11:40:56 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, mark424x@yahoo.com writes: Henry, 5gph at 15knots is quite good. Do you have a fuel flow meter - just curious if the consumption is fairly linear with speed up to that point or if there are big gains by dropping back to ~11-12? It seems that most folks either stay at 7-8 or crank it up to 15-16 if they are able. Could you also comment on the interior noise at cruise. Often the lightweight designs don't do great with noise isolation. Thanks, Mark