A catenary is defined as the shape of a perfectly flexible chain
suspended by
its ends and acted on by gravity.
Many boaters assume that if you do not use a snubber, the catenary of
the chain serves the same purpose. Pulling all that chain up off the
bottom absorbs a lot of energy.
But the idea that an anchor chain forms a perfect catenary is another
one of those maritime legends. Typically, in still water with no wind,
the chain hangs down from the bow until it rests on the bottom, then
proceeds horizontally to the anchor. As the wind picks up, enough chain
is lifted off the bottom to balance the wind pressure. This forms a
short catenary from the bow to the bottom. It is only when the wind is
quite strong that the chain is entirely lifted off the bottom forming a
true catenary from the bow to the anchor. Any increase in wind strength
flattens the shape of the catenary and provides a small amount of
snubbing action, much less than would be provided by an appropriately
sized nylon line. If the wind increases further, the chain becomes bar
tight and there is no snubbing. The main advantage of chain, considered
only from the perspective of anchor dragging, is that the weight tends
to keep the anchor shank parallel to the ground. There is no pull on
the anchor until the entire chain is lifted off the bottom. A similar
effect could be accomplished with a lighter chain or a nylon rode by
using a kellet or weight close to the anchor.
If you want to estimate exactly how much a boat will move backward when
the anchor rode is all chain, consider the following case. You are
anchored on a calm day in 10' of water. The bow is 5' above the water.
Being a traditionalist you use a 7:1 anchor rode, not forgetting to add
in the height of the bow. So you have a total of 105' of chain. Fifteen
feet of chain drops down directly from the bow and the remaining 90'
lies on the bottom directly to the anchor. The wind builds up to near
gale force. The chain is stretched bar tight. Because of the angle made
by the chain to the bottom, the boat moves back about 24 feet. For
shorter lengths of chain, the boat moves less. There is some snubbing
and shock attenuation action until the chain stretches tight. After
that there is none at all. If you want to increase the snubbing action
of a chain either increase the weight of the chain or fasten a
substantial kellet weight to the chain. The maximum snubbing effect is
when the kellet is placed close to the boat, preferably at the point
where the chain first hits the bottom, i.e. one anchoring depth. That
way the weight will have to be lifted off the bottom as the catenary
begins to form.
I put my money where my mouth is. My permanent mooring for a Willard
motorsailer was a 350 lb. mushroom with two waters depth of 3/4" chain.
This was shackled to a length of 1/2" chain, whose weight was supported
by a mooring buoy. From the mooring buoy a 3/4" polyester (Dacron)
pennant led to the boat. Polyester was chosen because for a short
mooring pennant I considered abrasion resistance more important than
elasticity. At the point where the 1/2" and 3/4" chains were shackled
together, I fastened a 50 lb lead weight. Any weight will do, even a
weight lifter's dumbell. Before the boat could pull on the mushroom,
the weight and the 3/4" chain had to be lifted off the bottom. The
mooring held my boat firm through two hurricanes while boats around
mine were being dashed on the rocks.
Larry Z