passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com

Passagemaking Under Power List

View all threads

SteadySailer58

DO
Dennis OConnor
Fri, Jul 7, 2006 11:51 AM

Let me be the group curmudgeon here...  It looks to me like he has the worst of all worlds in this design...

First it is a monohull with a less than 6:1 fineness ratio so 11 knots is just about it, downhill with the engine screaming and a 30 foot following sea curling over the transom...
It has hard chines which makes it quick to rebound roll, and rebound roll, and rebound roll, so he needs both a keel and sail to dampen the motion...
He has the engine shoehorned down in a narrow keel box which has to make maintenance just loads of fun...
He has the initial out of pocket expense and complications of installing and maintaining a large sail rigging while at the same time he has the initial out of pocket expense and complications of installing and maintaining a powerboat engine, wherebye he gets to continuously manage the sails whilst simultaneously burning diesel...
Not to mention the, "wonderful forward visibility", which consists of a 15 degree arc dead forward that is a wonderful view of the aft side of the mast...
In spite of of 831 sq. ft. of sail and a keel stuffed with a cast iron engine, he has to resort to drogue stabilizers to keep from hurling his lunch over the gunnel...
If I were a cynical person I might say I can see why he refused to do the drawings himself and have his name on it...  But since I am not, I won't...
There is an old guideline I try to follow in life, to whit:  Just because you can do something does not mean you should...

OK less sarcastically, all boats are compromises... This one has more than most..

denny


Sneak preview the  all-new Yahoo.com. It's not radically different. Just radically better.

Let me be the group curmudgeon here... It looks to me like he has the worst of all worlds in this design... First it is a monohull with a less than 6:1 fineness ratio so 11 knots is just about it, downhill with the engine screaming and a 30 foot following sea curling over the transom... It has hard chines which makes it quick to rebound roll, and rebound roll, and rebound roll, so he needs both a keel and sail to dampen the motion... He has the engine shoehorned down in a narrow keel box which has to make maintenance just loads of fun... He has the initial out of pocket expense and complications of installing and maintaining a large sail rigging while at the same time he has the initial out of pocket expense and complications of installing and maintaining a powerboat engine, wherebye he gets to continuously manage the sails whilst simultaneously burning diesel... Not to mention the, "wonderful forward visibility", which consists of a 15 degree arc dead forward that is a wonderful view of the aft side of the mast... In spite of of 831 sq. ft. of sail and a keel stuffed with a cast iron engine, he has to resort to drogue stabilizers to keep from hurling his lunch over the gunnel... If I were a cynical person I might say I can see why he refused to do the drawings himself and have his name on it... But since I am not, I won't... There is an old guideline I try to follow in life, to whit: Just because you can do something does not mean you should... OK less sarcastically, all boats are compromises... This one has more than most.. denny --------------------------------- Sneak preview the all-new Yahoo.com. It's not radically different. Just radically better.