Cruising America's Great Loop and other inland routes
View all threadsI am posting this to both Trawler World List and the Great Loop List, since
the recent question arose on the Loop List and my original call for help and
the many responses that I got were from TWL. Hope you don't mind getting
this twice.
SNIP>>>A boat that I'm interested in purchasing has iron fuel tanks. Would
appreciate any comments, pro or con, as to iron tanks versus aluminum or
fiberglass.<< (from the Loop List)
Miss Jackie is currently in the Keys Boat Works undergoing the major surgery
of having her iron, steel, whatever, rusting tanks replaced with Aluminum
tanks. We've been stuck in this hotel room for over three weeks now.
Virtually all Taiwanese and many other boats were built with ferrous metal
tanks, which, of course, don't rust from the oil-coated inside. If they are
not well-painted, as mine weren't, they can rust from the outside. And,
just like any other water damage that may occur on a boat, it's not the salt
water that causes the most problems, it's the fresh water that comes in
through leaks, open windows, or condensation.
The bottom of the tank has to sit on something. If the something is not
well thought out vis-à-vis moisture collection, the tank may sit in water.
Eventually, it will rust there, and unfortunately, the place it rusts, since
it is sitting on it, is very difficult to inspect (or repaint). In my case,
the leak is very difficult to see even with the tank out of the boat in
bright sunlight. The extensive rust tells me that they would have leaked
eventually, but most of the rusty spots did not leak. But then, it only
takes one, and the first one is the one that counts. ANY metal tank will
corrode if allowed to sit in water (except gold or silver, I guess).
My Aluminum tanks will outlast me and the boat. I consulted the TWList
(many thanks to all who responded), the Web, and local yard managers and
welders before specifying the tanks and means of protection. Here's what we
did (the tanks are 225 gallon saddle tanks with shapes that conform, sort
of, to the hull):
The tanks are fabricated of 3/16 5052 Aluminum with three fully welded
internal baffles (the old tanks were 1/8" steel, with two spot-welded
baffles). Connections to the tanks will be stainless steel.
The tanks are coated with Gluvit (an epoxy) before installation. This is
"belt and suspenders" protection, since Aluminum is self-protecting, but the
yard manager strongly recommended it. Aluminum Oxide is used for abrasive
grit, it is so hard.
The beds for the tanks are 3/4" plywood, coated with epoxy, attached to the
ribs of the boat (the old tanks sat directly on the ribs). 2"x4"'s are
fastened to the ribs vertically, and a 1/2" plywood bulkhead attached to
them. There is a 1" air space between the bottom of the bulkhead and the
tank bed.
2" rubber strips, 2" apart, are attached with 5200 to the bottoms and sides
of the tanks, ending about 1/4" from the corners, so there's no place for
water to collect and the tanks are nowhere sitting on wood or fiberglas.
A grounding tab was welded onto each of the tanks to provide a secure
connection to the ship's bonding system.
The bill for this is going to be around 20 BUs, however, we're having a lot
of other stuff done while the guys are in the bilge and the engines are out.
The original estimate was 16 BUs.
Dave and Marie Ross
Miss Jackie II
Tiger 41 Sundeck
Reston, Virginia
Docked in Marathon, Florida