Hi, Roger Hill here.
Although I sometimes enjoy reading the various topics that crop up on this
forum I don't often contribute, so here goes!
I have been away for a couple of weeks and only yesterday picked up on some
dialogue going on about fuel efficiency and comparisons between the Seles
and the Prowler VT950.
I designed the Seles cat so know a little about it and how it performs.
I don't actually know exactly what the fuel burn figures are for that boat
and am not sure how accurate they are. The 0.88L/NM figure at 15 knots is
presumably off their web site.
As a general rule I do not believe any statistics published about designs if
they are done so by someone with a vested or commercial interest in that
boat and I do not publish performance and fuel consumption figures of my own
designs unless they are the results from an independent test.
The Seles 10.2m and the Prowler 950 are of a similar size and displacement
(10.2m X 4.5m Seles versus 9.5m X 5.5m Prowler) but they are completely
different hull forms. The Seles cat is a pure displacement hull and the
Prowler is a planing hull (all be it a rather radical shape for a planing
hull) and by that fact alone it is extremely difficult to make direct
comparisons. The handling and sea keeping ability, stability, motion at rest
and in a seaway, etc. would all be quite different.
The optimal engine size for the Seles design is in a range of 50 to 70 hp
per side with outboards and I think that the Prowler is more than double
that amount.
The fuel consumption figures that I do have for a sister ship of the Seles
fitted with a pair of 60hp Yamaha 4 strokes, loaded displacement of 4,153kg
(Prowler has a published figure of 5,500kg loaded) range from 3700rpm, 12.75
knots, 1 L/NM both engines, 4300rpm, 15.6 knots, 1.28L, 5,500rpm, 21 knots,
1.8 L/NM.
For a reasonably well built (down to designed weight specified) planing cat
of similar dimensions we would expect (figures for a 9.5m planing cat fitted
with a pair of 200hp Evinrudes) at 4500rpm, 25 knots, 2.31 L/NM both engines
and a top speed of 38.1 knots.
The Seles cat was a 'one off' built in Auckland New Zealand and is currently
operating very successfully as a bare boat charter vessel in Queensland
Australia. There have been several of these 10m displacement hull cats built
with various layout and deck styling changes and there is currently underway
in Australia a new 10.65m production built version by Argus Boats.
The company that built the Seles cat has since been 'reformed' and is now
South Pacific Boat Builders.
I have no information on what the PDQ 34 goes like so have not included it
in this conversation.
To convert from metric to those old fashioned figures a US gallon is 3.785L,
a kilogram is 2.2046 lbs, and a metre is 3.281 feet.
Regards
Roger Hill