alternative power sources

DR
Dennis Raedeke
Mon, Nov 16, 2009 8:05 PM

Graham,

Ohms law proves that the higher the voltage the lower the power draw, so
using 24 volt equipment instead of 12 volt will require you to run a
generator for a shorter period of time to top up the batteries and this will
save fuel and put less carbon into the atmosphere

I think you should review ohm's law

P=I X E

Just because the voltage is higher that does not mean it takes less energy to
produce power.

Dennis Raedeke Wild Wind IV

Graham, Ohms law proves that the higher the voltage the lower the power draw, so using 24 volt equipment instead of 12 volt will require you to run a generator for a shorter period of time to top up the batteries and this will save fuel and put less carbon into the atmosphere I think you should review ohm's law P=I X E Just because the voltage is higher that does not mean it takes less energy to produce power. Dennis Raedeke Wild Wind IV
HC
Henry Clews
Mon, Nov 16, 2009 8:46 PM

It's fun to speculate about the possibilities of alternative power
sources for boats.  But, as a practical matter, simplicity plus tried
and true, seem to work best - if it's reliability you want.  We have
just completed another southbound trip on Sno' Dog, our PDQ 34 - again
without a single mechanical problem.  Since 2006, we've logged over
15,000 nautical miles and have over 1500 hours on our twin 4JH3
Yanmars - haven't had single a mechanical problem.

Along the ICW this fall, we met a number of boaters struggling with
mechanical issues, some awaiting the delivery of parts so they could
continue on their way.  We also noted a surprising number of calls to
Sea Tow for one reason or another.

Diesel/Electric Hybrid systems work well in cars because of
regenerative braking, but this really doesn't apply to boats.  There
may be some applications where it makes sense, for very low-powered
vessels (like Endeavour's new Electric Boat) but few people are
content to travel that slowly nowadays.

I think many experienced boaters make do with a good set of house
batteries (enough to carry their needs for 24 hours) plus an inverter
to supply 115 VAC as needed.  The batteries can be recharged by the
engines, a generator, or possibly with solar or wind power.  The only
fly in the ointment is air conditioning.  The need for AC can be
greatly reduced by moving around with the seasons - on Sno' Dog we use
more heat than AC!  Plus, we have many opening ports & hatches.  (We
have a grand total of 65 hours on our generator!)

Henry Clews
Jensen Beach, FL
most recent blog:  www.snodoglog.com/09Fall-Pg3.html

It's fun to speculate about the possibilities of alternative power sources for boats. But, as a practical matter, simplicity plus tried and true, seem to work best - if it's reliability you want. We have just completed another southbound trip on Sno' Dog, our PDQ 34 - again without a single mechanical problem. Since 2006, we've logged over 15,000 nautical miles and have over 1500 hours on our twin 4JH3 Yanmars - haven't had single a mechanical problem. Along the ICW this fall, we met a number of boaters struggling with mechanical issues, some awaiting the delivery of parts so they could continue on their way. We also noted a surprising number of calls to Sea Tow for one reason or another. Diesel/Electric Hybrid systems work well in cars because of regenerative braking, but this really doesn't apply to boats. There may be some applications where it makes sense, for very low-powered vessels (like Endeavour's new Electric Boat) but few people are content to travel that slowly nowadays. I think many experienced boaters make do with a good set of house batteries (enough to carry their needs for 24 hours) plus an inverter to supply 115 VAC as needed. The batteries can be recharged by the engines, a generator, or possibly with solar or wind power. The only fly in the ointment is air conditioning. The need for AC can be greatly reduced by moving around with the seasons - on Sno' Dog we use more heat than AC! Plus, we have many opening ports & hatches. (We have a grand total of 65 hours on our generator!) Henry Clews Jensen Beach, FL most recent blog: www.snodoglog.com/09Fall-Pg3.html
GK
Georgs Kolesnikovs
Mon, Nov 16, 2009 9:24 PM

Hey, Dennis!

Good to hear you chime in. Where is the well-traveled Wild Wind IV at
these days? What's in the near future for your powercat?

--Georgs

Dennis Raedeke Wild Wind IV

Hey, Dennis! Good to hear you chime in. Where is the well-traveled Wild Wind IV at these days? What's in the near future for your powercat? --Georgs > Dennis Raedeke Wild Wind IV