trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Re: T&T: roll chocks

BS
Bob Salmons
Sun, Apr 12, 2020 9:53 PM

I have had roll chocks aboard my Willard 40 Veronica for over a decade.
They were designed and installed by eyeball and work extremely well.  There
is no noticeable effect on handling or fuel burn.  They are not magic, but
have eliminated the proverbial Willard "death roll" and make most chop
endurable.  They also work while at anchor.You will find a page in the
current edition of Voyaging Under Power.

Roll chocks are properly called oblique bilge keels.  Old fashioned ship's
lifeboats had them.  They would double as hand holds if capsized and could
assist a person in the water clambering aboard when upright.

In a slow, full displacement hull, design is not critical, IMHO.  I don't
think they would work on a high-speed or semi-displacement hull.

British sailboats often had twin keels.  Not the same thing at all.  They
were designed to be stable in a drying mooring, at the cost of upwind
ability.  The Westerly Centaur is probably the best known twin-keeler.

The ability to take the ground is a weakness of bilge keels.  Mine will
breakaway rather than risk holing the hull.  I also show travel lift
operators pictures so they know where to place straps.  They can make
blocking the hull a little more involved, but nothing most yards can't deal
with.

They are designed to allow crabpot buoys to slide off and have never caused
a problem with fouling an anchor rode in a tidal anchorage.

In my opinion, on a full displacement round bottomed boat, they are an
ideal solution.  Most competent yards could probably install them

Bob Salmons
Veronica, Willard 40 RPH

> > I have had roll chocks aboard my Willard 40 Veronica for over a decade. > They were designed and installed by eyeball and work extremely well. There > is no noticeable effect on handling or fuel burn. They are not magic, but > have eliminated the proverbial Willard "death roll" and make most chop > endurable. They also work while at anchor.You will find a page in the > current edition of *Voyaging Under Powe*r. > Roll chocks are properly called oblique bilge keels. Old fashioned ship's lifeboats had them. They would double as hand holds if capsized and could assist a person in the water clambering aboard when upright. In a slow, full displacement hull, design is not critical, IMHO. I don't think they would work on a high-speed or semi-displacement hull. British sailboats often had twin keels. Not the same thing at all. They were designed to be stable in a drying mooring, at the cost of upwind ability. The Westerly Centaur is probably the best known twin-keeler. The ability to take the ground is a weakness of bilge keels. Mine will breakaway rather than risk holing the hull. I also show travel lift operators pictures so they know where to place straps. They can make blocking the hull a little more involved, but nothing most yards can't deal with. They are designed to allow crabpot buoys to slide off and have never caused a problem with fouling an anchor rode in a tidal anchorage. In my opinion, on a full displacement round bottomed boat, they are an ideal solution. Most competent yards could probably install them Bob Salmons Veronica, Willard 40 RPH
ET
Eric Thoman
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 12:14 AM

When we were designing our boat (over 2o years ago...wow time flies) I asked
the naval architect a million questions.  One was: Why not add bilge keels?
It seemed like free roll reduction.  His response was it is risky on a
one-off boat.  It really should be tank tested which would have been
prohibitively expensive in our case.  His further explanation was that water
does not necessarily flow straight down your hull like you would think. The
size and shape and location needs to be right or you take a chance on
buggering up your carefully designed slippery hull.

Don't just eat the chocolate bunny ears today...

Eric Thoman
Abyssinia

When we were designing our boat (over 2o years ago...wow time flies) I asked the naval architect a million questions. One was: Why not add bilge keels? It seemed like free roll reduction. His response was it is risky on a one-off boat. It really should be tank tested which would have been prohibitively expensive in our case. His further explanation was that water does not necessarily flow straight down your hull like you would think. The size and shape and location needs to be right or you take a chance on buggering up your carefully designed slippery hull. Don't just eat the chocolate bunny ears today... Eric Thoman Abyssinia