Ancedotal information abounds for all sort of motion sickness remedies. Unfortunately most of these are not of any real proven value--at least under scientific double blind studies. As Peter notes a side effect of high doses (and in some people even as low as 600 mg) of vitamine C will be gastrointestional upset, including diarrhea and vomiting. There may be some slight antihistamine effect of vitamine C--but not enough to warrent its use in motion sickness. Dramanine and Meclazine are the drugs of choice which have antihistaminic qualities.
My views for treatment and prevention of motionsickness have been posted in T & T a number of times so I shall not repeat them at this point. Suffice it to say, it if works for you--then use it.
Regards,
Bob Austin M.D.
Well, a recent show on "Mythbusters" found ginger cookies to be more
effective that anything else except prescription drugs but had the
added bonus that they didnt make you drowsy. AND...they did a sort of
double blind in that they also threw in placebos on both "victims"
which exposed one of the "victims" tendency to be healed by what he
believed would heal him. But the other was apparently a reliable test
"victim" in that the placebo didn't help him AT ALL.
I always carry Ginger Snaps when I have "unknown entities" aboard.
On 11/29/05, Bob Austin thataway4@cox.net wrote:
Ancedotal information abounds for all sort of motion sickness remedies. Unfortunately most of these are not of any real proven value--at least under scientific double blind studies. As Peter notes a side effect of high doses (and in some people even as low as 600 mg) of vitamine C will be gastrointestional upset, including diarrhea and vomiting. There may be some slight antihistamine effect of vitamine C--but not enough to warrent its use in motion sickness. Dramanine and Meclazine are the drugs of choice which have antihistaminic qualities.
My views for treatment and prevention of motionsickness have been posted in T & T a number of times so I shall not repeat them at this point. Suffice it to say, it if works for you--then use it.
Regards,
Bob Austin M.D.
Passagemaking-Under-Power Mailing List
--
Jim Isbell
"If you are not living on the edge, well then,
you are just taking up too much space."
Perhaps this has yet been mentioned but many offshore sailors swore by
Sturgeron, an over the counter blood pressure drug sold in Europe. When I
raced my 65' ultralight from Victoria, British Columbia to Maui, 2 out of
the 10 member crew who were particularly subject to motion sickness used
it with no side effects. But like all of the drug remedies these are
chemicals that are foreign to your body. In any event it worked well for
these 2 who had never been offshore before but had frequently been sick in
inshore sailing. But the highest winds we experienced were 40 knots and
once we got past the Washington and Oregon coasts and "turned right"
around the Pacific High at about the latitude of San Francisco it was all
downwind/offwind surfing between 15 and 20 knots which makes for a faily
stable ride.
Cheers,
Roger Elmes