<Scott wrote......Finally, what do you think of electro optical isolators
for the GPS and other serial interfaces? Easier to simply convert to RS232
physical connectors and disconnect? And finally, component or composite
video?>
Perhaps there are some opti isolators that are rated a thousands of volt but
I doubt it. Most are designed to eliminate ground loops and provide "low"
voltage isolation.
Again I have to believe that you need to keep it out of the boat. Once
inside then all of man's efforts will be fried in the EMF display that the
current/voltage of a strike will broadcast within the boat.
We recently were involved in a lightening strike claim in Venezuela. This on
a sailboat sitting on Jack stands in a boat yard. The lightening strike
happen to be observed by me purely by chance sitting in the pilothouse of
Swan Song watching the strikes in the close area. This one was some 200
yards for us.
The strike hit the mast head vaporizing the antenna and wind instrument and
then a big puff of smoke as the backstay SSB insulator exploded. Then we
don't exactly know where it went but there were surface burns on the hull
between the bronze thru hulls and the closest jack stand. In the rear stbd
quarter below the waterline there was a burned hole the size of a dime with
arc traces to another jackstand.
We surmised that the charge was therefore inside the boat looking for ways
to equalize the ground/sky potential of the strike. This boat was fully
bonded and had lightening protection as best that could be provided.
The small hole in the hull turned into a platter sized area of charred
delaminated fiberglass/resin. We couldn't see why it chose this area of
major exit vs. any other but so be it.
Ultra sounding the entire rest of the boat's hull showed no other areas of
concern. The area was repaired and the boat launched to check on the systems
aboard.
Virtually everything from the VHF/SSB to all the air conditioners,
generator, engine electrics, electric toilets, on and on were dead or
limping. Basically it needed a complete refit of the entire electrical
system. Not easy to do in a 58' production sailboat.
So here is a recent first hand case of what the huge amount of
current/voltage can do. Granted this boat was on the hard but the keel which
was the lightening ground was 2" from the saturated ground beneath it. Why
the potential inside the boat decided to take many alternate paths to
relieve the potential difference remains a bit of a mystery.
I doubt if a few opti isolators or even disconnecting the power leads unless
completely removing the units from the area of the incoming wires would have
saved these devices.
My concern with these discussions and some of the papers and info that we
all can look at and read is that we may think we have a solution to the
effects and danger of lightening strikes. I submit that no matter what
course of snake oil that you apply to the issue it is still snake oil.
If Mother Nature decides to lay one on you directly the outcome will vary
and it will not be pretty and not what it said in your "manual's"
troubleshooting section. If you are still of a conscious mind and can deal
with what ever has been dealt out great. If not then what an adventure up
till then ;-)
As always YMMV,
Cheers
Dave & Nancy
Swan Song
Roughwater 58
Caribbean Cruise '07