Hi Dan
With 6 surveys under my belt this past year, I must be the most experienced
guy on the List on this subject.
In the end, a good surveyor is really cheap, and I don't have a single
regret about the costs involved. Each of the deals I walked away from saved
me money and grief, and on the one I closed, he saved me several times the
total cost of all 6 surveys, because his report gave me grounds to
negotiate a against a faint possibility that might - or might not - become
a significant problem in the distant future. I was also lucky in having a
good broker and an ethical seller.
I actually only used 2 marine surveyors, one in Seattle, and one in both
Vancouver and Victoria. I used 5 different mechanical surveyors for obvious
reasons.
In each and every case, I got a separate oral but full debriefing from both
surveyors about all the major findings immediately after the survey,
including rough estimates of cost to repair. The mechanics faxed only a
page of terse comments on each finding within 48 hours, often hand-written.
Interestingly, none found any major engine problems on any of the 6 boats,
but lots of potentially expensive minor ones such as hoses, raw water pumps
etc., and one mechanic did discover that on one of the boats, the
engine-transmission combinations were completely different. Halfway through
the Seattle boat, the surveyor recommended I walk, and when he charged me
for only half a survey, I told him I wouldn't need a report. In the other 5
cases, I have formal, detailed surveys that run 20 to 30 pages each, and
them by mail in about a 7-10 days.
On the first boat I had surveyed and rejected, a broker told a subsequent
prospective purchaser that he might be able to save some money by buying a
copy of my report. (The owner, another honorable seller, had disclosed the
general nature of the findings to the broker and re-priced the boat
accordingly.) I then phoned the surveyor to ask if might re-sell a copy. He
said that the survey was my property exclusively, to do with as I pleased,
and he certainly had no objection to my selling it.
In light of my experience, your surveyor's conduct is at least curious and
inappropriate, but hopefully will prove to be nothing more than a
misunderstanding e.g. that the broker was to pass a sealed envelope on to
you. However, I'd withhold payment until I checked his professional
competence and integrity just in case you have to have the boat
re-surveyed. Until you get credible reassurance, you will wonder whether he
was working for you or the broker, i.e. whether you can trust his findings.
Start by asking the local Power Squadron officers and go from there.
I know that it's a real disappointment to have to wait even longer for
something you really want, but this is one of the bigger expenses of your
life. As noted above, good/good surveyors are cheap. On the other hand, bad
ones can prove incredibly expensive.
Hope it works out quickly and successfully.
Cheers, Garrett