passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com

Passagemaking Under Power List

View all threads

Unsailboat fuel consumption

WL
Willy Loyd
Tue, Aug 29, 2006 4:32 PM

Idlewild is powered by a 55-hp Kubota which, Ben Gray told me in
Vancouver, generally ran at 15-20 hp sipping just a tad more than 1
gph.

For greatest efficiency, you want to be skinny as well modestly-powered.

--Georgs

The boys also added they over propped, using an over pitched four bladed
prop. Compared to the best match three blade they had. Working the power
hard at low RPM. Experience from Bens earlier test runs, he changed the prop
for there intended use if I remember correctly.

Willy
Invader no 1
39 kishi conversion

>Idlewild is powered by a 55-hp Kubota which, Ben Gray told me in >Vancouver, generally ran at 15-20 hp sipping just a tad more than 1 >gph. >For greatest efficiency, you want to be skinny as well modestly-powered. >--Georgs The boys also added they over propped, using an over pitched four bladed prop. Compared to the best match three blade they had. Working the power hard at low RPM. Experience from Bens earlier test runs, he changed the prop for there intended use if I remember correctly. Willy Invader no 1 39 kishi conversion
RR
Ron Rogers
Tue, Aug 29, 2006 8:14 PM

Didn't they have something done to the prop in Australia when they were
hauled? I don't believe that you achieve efficiency by over-propping, but
I'm willing to learn. I just finished eliminating over-propping on my
Willard 40 and she clearly runs easier.

Ron Rogers

----- Original Message -----
From: "Willy Loyd" cfeinc@telus.net

| >Idlewild is powered by a 55-hp Kubota which, Ben Gray told me in
| >Vancouver, generally ran at 15-20 hp sipping just a tad more than 1
| >gph.
|
| >For greatest efficiency, you want to be skinny as well modestly-powered.
|
| >--Georgs
|
|
| The boys also added they over propped, using an over pitched four bladed
| prop. Compared to the best match three blade they had. Working the power
| hard at low RPM. Experience from Bens earlier test runs, he changed the
prop
| for there intended use if I remember correctly.

Didn't they have something done to the prop in Australia when they were hauled? I don't believe that you achieve efficiency by over-propping, but I'm willing to learn. I just finished eliminating over-propping on my Willard 40 and she clearly runs easier. Ron Rogers ----- Original Message ----- From: "Willy Loyd" <cfeinc@telus.net> | >Idlewild is powered by a 55-hp Kubota which, Ben Gray told me in | >Vancouver, generally ran at 15-20 hp sipping just a tad more than 1 | >gph. | | >For greatest efficiency, you want to be skinny as well modestly-powered. | | >--Georgs | | | The boys also added they over propped, using an over pitched four bladed | prop. Compared to the best match three blade they had. Working the power | hard at low RPM. Experience from Bens earlier test runs, he changed the prop | for there intended use if I remember correctly.
JH
John Harris
Tue, Aug 29, 2006 10:19 PM

Engineering theory generally would say that producing the same horsepower at
a lower RPM will reduce fuel consumption, therefore overproping i.e. more
distance per revolution will improve fuel consumption, maybe to the extent
of a few percent.

This is still a bad idea because it reduces the ability of the motor to
produce proper RPM for maximum horsepower resulting in reduced top speed,
and increased risk of damaging the motor at the maximum speed the engine
will drive the boat.

John Harris

Engineering theory generally would say that producing the same horsepower at a lower RPM will reduce fuel consumption, therefore overproping i.e. more distance per revolution will improve fuel consumption, maybe to the extent of a few percent. This is still a bad idea because it reduces the ability of the motor to produce proper RPM for maximum horsepower resulting in reduced top speed, and increased risk of damaging the motor at the maximum speed the engine will drive the boat. John Harris