I have now been disappointed three times with Ebay 720a's. All were DOA
completely or failed self-calibration horribly. These 720a's were sold by
individuals at around the $1000USD mark.
I can purchase a refurbished and guaranteed 720a for around $3000.00. If
one is establishing a modest, and easy to keep in repair home metrology
lab, maybe an older Fluke 5000 series calibrator is the way to go? The
older calibrators are being offered, again by individuals, or surplus
businesses, for around $950USD. The guaranteed working 5440b's go for
$2000USD without calibration. There may be more hope, that a used
calibrator, with its built in protective circuitry, can be purchased
surplus with more success than the 720a. The 720a divider resistors are too
easily cooked by idiots. In addition, from my own sad experience, the
sealed "A" switch on the 720a has a much shorter lifetime than the open
wafer switches. Thus, even the refurbished 720a may suffer an "A" switch
failure shortly after the warranty period expires.
IMHO, a 720a only makes sense if you buy new for business purposes.
Why have I felt the need for a 720a?
Can a Fluke 5000 series calibrator take the place of a Kelvin-Varley
divider in all of the above procedures?
Suggestions Welcome,
Stan
A fluke 5440B would come close if you had a way to calibrate it every 30
days.
You can come close but you will need 10 volts and a good null meter to
calibrate it at 10 volts on the 10 volt and 20 volt ranges. You can stop
here but you should really use a divider to get the 1000, 100, 2 and .1
volt points it would really like calibrated.
You can use an HP 3458A 10K ohms and 10 volts to get about the same thing.
Use the 3458A to replace the 720A divider and null meter. The transfer
standard / linearity specs are close to a 720A
The 5100 is more versatile but not as stable as the 5440 and a lot harder
to calibrate.
On Wed, Apr 22, 2015 at 9:24 PM, Stan Katz stan.katz.hk@gmail.com wrote:
I have now been disappointed three times with Ebay 720a's. All were DOA
completely or failed self-calibration horribly. These 720a's were sold by
individuals at around the $1000USD mark.
I can purchase a refurbished and guaranteed 720a for around $3000.00. If
one is establishing a modest, and easy to keep in repair home metrology
lab, maybe an older Fluke 5000 series calibrator is the way to go? The
older calibrators are being offered, again by individuals, or surplus
businesses, for around $950USD. The guaranteed working 5440b's go for
$2000USD without calibration. There may be more hope, that a used
calibrator, with its built in protective circuitry, can be purchased
surplus with more success than the 720a. The 720a divider resistors are too
easily cooked by idiots. In addition, from my own sad experience, the
sealed "A" switch on the 720a has a much shorter lifetime than the open
wafer switches. Thus, even the refurbished 720a may suffer an "A" switch
failure shortly after the warranty period expires.
IMHO, a 720a only makes sense if you buy new for business purposes.
Why have I felt the need for a 720a?
Can a Fluke 5000 series calibrator take the place of a Kelvin-Varley
divider in all of the above procedures?
Suggestions Welcome,
Stan
volt-nuts mailing list -- volt-nuts@febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to
https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/volt-nuts
and follow the instructions there.
--
John Phillips