To: "Donald C. Burdick" burdickd@email.msn.com
Cc: trawler-world-list@samurai.com
Subject: Re: TWL: Re: Hull Speed
It is my understanding that it not a particularly accurate rule that one can
multiply the sq root of the waterline length times 1.34 to find the max
speed of
a displacement hull. The actual max speed is a function of the hull
design. (It
will be approximately available by this calculation) Stated another way,
the
S/L is the sq root of the length times the maximum hull speed, but not a
final
determiner of actual hull speed of any given boat. (or at any speed for that
matter).
I suspect the only truly accurate way for a boat owner to arrive at maximum
mileage is to use a fuel measuring device such as Flowscan and make accurate
runs knowing current and bottom condition of the hull.
Regarding my Nordic Tug, I have studied Cummins's fuel burn curves at given
RPM
which has Nordic Tug's speed rates overlaid (not very accurate) and have
come
close to finding efficient points of operation, but there are so many
conditions
that enter into how efficiently a given hull moves thru the water as to
make any
estimate with less than a 10% accuracy almost a single boat type of deal.
Robert Murch
Endeavor, Deer Harbor, WA
Donald C. Burdick wrote:
The bottom line is that every boat has a hull speed.
... Yet, I
believe our most fuel efficient speed is about 8.5 knots (1700 rpm's with
24" diameter three blade 16" pitch propellers). This is slightly less
than
the theoretical hull speed of 8.67 knots as calculated by the square root
of
our waterline in feet times 1.34.
But, others tell me the most efficient full displacement rate of travel is
only 70% of theoretical hull speed. For our vessel, that calculates to
6.07
knots.
Where do I find Grand Banks data, or from any other manufacturers of full
displacement or semi-displacement hulls, addressing fuel efficiency to
maximize cruising range? There must be some published chart curves out
there.