After my short post about the stability calculations of my Willard Horizon, I
received several anxious e-mails from trawler owners about the stability of
their own vessels. In addition there were a couple of additional e-mails about
the equations used to calculate stability. The calculations for reserve or
ultimate stability of BALLASTED DISPLACEMENT hulls are fully described in Dave
Gerr's article in the October 2004 issue of Sail magazine and in most texts on
boat design. These calculations are largely irrelevant for most of the trawlers
owned by members of this list - so not to worry.
RESERVE STABILITY is defined by Gerr as the number of degrees a boat can heel
and still right itself. If tipped beyond this point the boat will continue to
capsize. The angle at which capsize occurs is called the angle of vanishing
stability (AVS). If you see the glass as half full, it is often referred to as
the range of positive stability. The AVS is of great concern to owners of
ocean going sailboats because they are subject to sail forces which cause them to
heel and unusually strong wind gusts which might lay them flat on their sides.
To provide a restoring force, sailboats carry heavy ballast placed as low in
the hull or keel as possible. To be considered safe, ocean going sailboats
should have a range of positive stability of 115 to 120 degrees or more. More is
better. Trawlers, unless they have an unusually high tophamper are generally
not subject to the same wind forces, nor do they carry a high percentage of
their weight in ballast.
Semi-displacement trawler hull stability comes largely from the relatively
flat shape of the underbody which tends to strongly resist tipping. However,
once knocked down to 90 degrees, few modern trawlers will recover. Such a
situation is rare unless the boat is hit broadside by a breaking wave with a height
greater than the trawler's beam. That's what small craft warnings are for. It
is possible to design unballasted hulls which are self righting (i.e., USCG
surf boats) however not many recreational trawler owners would put up with the
design compromises necessary to do so.
Trawlers with pure displacement hulls (i.e., Nordhavns, Willards, and
Krogens, etc.) have soft chines and carry some ballast so the stability calculations
are more meaningful. Basically the calculations consider the draft of the hull
excluding the keel, the displacement, the weight of the ballast, and the
overall beam. I'm not going to give the equations here because I remember the flap
caused when I discussed Keith's formula for determining engine power required
to achieve a given speed. If you want to do the stability calculations for
yourself, do the research to find the formulas and measurements you need.
More meaningful to trawler owners is the CAPSIZE SCREENING NUMBER. This
simply estimates the resistance of a hull to capsize when hit on the beam by a
sudden transient force like a wave or wind gust. The capsize number is simply the
boat's overall beam divided by the cube root of the displacement volume in
cubic feet.
C = Beam/((displacement in lbs/64)^.334)
Boats with screening numbers under 2 are considered resistant to capsize.
Quite simply, the heavier and beamier a boat, the more resistant to capsize. It
stands to reason that canoes and kayaks are more likely to capsize than garbage
scows.
None of this predicts how seakindly a boat will be in rough weather. Indeed,
boats which have very high degrees of stability can give a rather unpleasant
ride. It's like the springs on your car. Stiff springs are best for cornering
but you feel every bump in the road. Nothing like my old Buick three hole
Roadmaster.
Larry Z