Hi Mark,
ABYC does recommend standards for boat building and I'm sure most builders
adhere to it, but there can always be the occasional slip by an individual
tradesman that may not appear until something goes wrong.
ABS certification for a complete build is a long and expensive process that
is usually only asked for by owners of boats over 75' to be sure they get
the quality they are paying for. It requires plan approval before the work
can commence to ensure the engineering meets their criteria. Once
construction commences there are regular survey inspections at various
stages along the way and this is to ensure engineering practices are adhered
to. The inspections are similar but not as intense as having a project
manager oversee every part of the build, but you do get a certificate from
the classification society stating that it complies with their rules and
classification can earn you an insurance discount and a better resale value.
A design team for a project can consist of ten or more or it can be as few
as two. Sometimes the smaller team can be more efficient if it consists of
a very experienced designer and a naval architect/engineer. If it's a
production boat it will be easier to amortize the design costs over a
shorter period of time. Be assured the design costs have to be recovered,
as do the tooling costs, production costs, dealer fees and warranty
allowances and in the end everyone must make a reasonable profit. This is
why some custom boats don't cost much more than some production boats.
It certainly does help save time and money if you're a hands on type of guy
when it comes to diagnosing and fixing small problems on your boat. If you
have to call someone in every time something goes wrong then long range
cruising may not be a good idea for you. You could take along a friend or a
crew member who can find and fix things for you. A good 'fixer' may also
find a problem before it becomes serious enough that it curtails your
cruise.
Going serious cruising must be taken seriously. You can't just buy a boat
and go offshore cruising with no real experience, although some people have
done it and survived it's not recommended. Before you buy a boat do your
own inspection or have a survey done by a reputable surveyor, even on a
production boat if you're going to trust your life and your bank account to
this boat. Once you buy the boat that best suits your requirements you then
need to gain experience on it. It's not a conundrum so much as a process
that you need to go through before buying the boat and then before taking
the final step to go cruising.
Cheers,
Graham
Captain Graham Pfister
President & Principle Designer
TrawlerCat Marine Designs
Message: 5
Date: Sun, 15 Nov 2009 13:36:56 -0800 (PST)
From: Mark mark424x@yahoo.com
To: Power Catamaran List power-catamaran@lists.samurai.com
Subject: Re: [PCW] Buzzards Bay 34 pricing
Message-ID: 977041.30777.qm@web31809.mail.mud.yahoo.com
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
In building construction, many of these issues are dealt with by the local
building codes, e.g. you can't have a hidden splice or even a junction box
that is not accessible, must follow color code standards....Contractors can
loose their license if they don't comply. Occasionally we hear about ABS or
CE certifications, do they cover any of these things or is it really only
about seaworthness of the hull design?
In many industries there a whole teams that focus on "design for" issues,
such design for manufacturability, design for maintenance, design for
quality, etc. It doesn't seem that there is the scale in this industry to
absorb those kinds of costs.
I was chatting the other day with a fellow that had a circumnavigation cut
short due to some mechanical and budget issues. He went on and on about
the poor quality of the marine maintenance services, even in the high priced
boat yards here in southern California and mentioned some of the issues that
Ed cited.
It certainly is a conundrum.
Mark
Mark Long
Marina del Rey, CA