I subscribe to the Marine Electronics edition of the Ocean Navigator
Email Newsletter. In the issue I received this morning was an article
by Larry McKenna discussing the Euroopean version of GPS, called
Galileo, along with some comments on the US version of GPS. Included in
it was the following:
Finally, for no other reason than you can't contest the results of a
head-to-head comparison of marine electronics, I offer this little
tidbit from Don White in Ontario about WAAS:
While researching for a basic GPS course I was writing, I had the
opportunity to have a couple of WAAS-capable Garmin GPSs and a Magellan
Meridian Marine unit to compare. Standing in my driveway with the GPS76
in one hand and the Meridian Marine in the other, the Magellan will
pick up and lock on to both the Atlantic West Inmarsat (54 degrees
west) and the Atlantic East Inmarsat (15.5 degrees West). The GPS76
could not even pick up the Atlantic West satellite at 33 degrees above
the horizon! The Garmins would show (estimated position errors) of 26
to 55 feet; the Magellan was stable in WAAS mode, about a 9-foot error.
Neither of the two other Garmin e-Trex units could pick-up the WAAS
satellites. I suspect the antenna design was (is?) the culprit.
Rick Quarles
Barric II, Nordic Tug 32-147
New Bern, NC