The History Channel had a show "Killer Storm"--today. This is the "Perfect
storm"--Late Oct 1991. What makes this unique amounst ocean storms is that it
was tracked extensively, studied extensively by NOAA and involved many
vessels, but was fairly close to the US and Canadian Mainland's. Winds
reached gusts of 80 knots and waves estimated at as much as 60 feet. The
footage in the History channel show is impressive. There are many storms,
including hurricanes and cyclones which are far more severe. More boats and
lives lost in the Queens Day Storm off New Zealand, the 1998 Sydney to Hobart
Race and the 1979 Fastnet race. Most boats involved in these latter storms
were sailboats--and very few were purpose built power passagemakers.
My personal experience was with a storm similar to the "Killer
Storm"--sustained winds in excess of 65 knots, gusts to over 80 knots, Seas at
least 45 feet. The boat was a full displacement, deep keel 53 foot on deck
motor sailor, and the hull form was double ended under the water, with a high
wineglass shaped transom. The hull had 30% of the weight in ballast. The aft
cabin structure was as strong or stronger than the foreword pilot house. This
configuration (full displacement, deep draft, double ended under water) is
also an excellent ocean passagemaking hull form it is an easily driven hull
and tracks well under severe conditions.
I had read all of the books--including reports of previous documented storms,
rollings and pitchpollings and a number of personal communications with people
who had lost their boats by rolling or pitch polling. Our severe storm was in
the middle of the North Atlantic, so there was no place hide. Three boats and
about 28 lives were lost in this storm. There were other similar boats within
VHF range. Two of us depended on auto pilots and one had a large crew--but no
functioning auto pilot. In this situation, the first thought is to not allow
the boat to come sideways to the waves--for the reasons Mike stated--a 20 foot
breaking wave could capsize a 52 foot boat. A sea greater than 50 feet would
pitchpole the boat. We did not yet have series drogues (for drogues and sea
anchors see Earl Hinz's book: "Heavy Weather Tactics using Sea Anchors and
Drogues"). I did have material which could have made a drogue (I had several
large tires and 4x4 timbers chained together and ready to go)--but series
drogues are much better for running--and I would carry one in today's world.
We steered quartering off of the seas--boat speed 6 to 7 knots. Even with
breaking waves, the prop and large rudder, (about 6 feet from top to bottom)
rarely came out of the water. A very small sail kept the bow down wind. The
boat would pick up speed as it went down a wave face, and then the breaking
part would break over the boat--Although we did not broach--we did get at
least partially sideways--and/or were hit by wave trains from the side--the
boat rolled to 90 degrees once--over 60 degrees several times. A very heavy
duty auto pilot did keep the boat relitatively on course. The boat without an
auto pilot was a much greater risk--and had more damage. People became
fatigued and made mistakes.
The crew (2 of us) stayed in the pilot house or lower cabin amidships to
attempt sleep (very difficult because of noise and motion). There was a great
fatigue factor. Keeping prop wash against the rudder was important--since it
allowed rudder response, even in turbulent breaking water--the small sail also
helped in directional stability. If the situation had detiorrated to the
point where I was concerned about pitchpolling I would have employed the
drogue on a very long line--however I was aware of another boat, where when
the stern was in the breaking part of the wave, as the bow was down, the wrap
from the drogue became tangled in the prop--disabling the power option. I
think that the quartering off also makes pitch polling less possible (going
back to my surfing days--where quartering was much safer than running straight
down large waves)
A trawler which will encounter severe heavy weather should also have: high
displacement, be ballasted, double ended or canoe stern, strongly built aft
deckhouse, large rudder and a series drogue would be my choice. My personal
feeling is that the boat would fair better quartering off than heading into
the seas.
We and several other larger boats had much more damage attempting to go thru
the Straits of Gibraltar against 50 knots of wind and only 15 feet of steep
seas.
The books to have aboard would include "Heavy Weather Sailing", "The Annapolis
Book of Seamanship", Steve Dashew's "Surviving the Storm", Larry Pardy's
"Storm Tactics Handbook", "Heavy Weather Tactics Using Sea Anchors and
Drogues", Shane's "Drag device data Base" and Shewmon's "The Sea Anchor and
Drogues".
May you never encounter this situation.
Bob Austin